PSP vs MVR vs CDLIS: A Three-Way Comparison of What Each Report Actually Shows
Last updated:
Run an MVR — from $40
Same-day digital delivery. Five packages from $40 (MVR Basic) through $100 (DOT Pre-Employment with FMCSA Clearinghouse). Optional $25 DQ File template.
Run a reportThree different federal-or-federally-supervised data sources sit at the heart of CDL pre-employment screening: the Pre-Employment Screening Program (PSP), the Motor Vehicle Record (MVR), and the Commercial Driver License Information System (CDLIS). They are often discussed in the same breath, are sometimes ordered as a single bundle, and are routinely confused with one another by carriers running their first hire. They are not interchangeable. Each surfaces a different slice of the driver's history, each is governed by different federal authority, and skipping any one of them on a CDL hire leaves a documented gap in the §391.23 pre-employment file.
This guide breaks down each report side by side: who runs it, what it shows, what it does not show, and where each one fits into the CDL pre-employment workflow.
The 30-second comparison
- MVR — state DMV transcript of one driver's license history in one state. The most detailed and granular of the three for ordinary traffic violations.
- CDLIS — federal pointer database that lists every state where a driver has ever held a CDL or CDL learner's permit. Tells you which MVRs to pull.
- PSP — FMCSA-administered database of crash and roadside-inspection records pulled from MCMIS. Tells you about on-the-road history at prior carriers, not license-status history.
Each one fills a different gap. None of them is a substitute for any of the others.
Side-by-side comparison
| Attribute | MVR | CDLIS | PSP |
|---|---|---|---|
| Source | State DMV | AAMVA federal index | FMCSA / MCMIS |
| Scope | One state at a time | All states where driver held a CDL | All carriers in prior 5 years |
| License status | Yes (in that state) | Yes (every CDL state) | No |
| Convictions | Yes (citation-level) | No (status only) | No |
| Crash history | State-recorded only | No | Yes (5 years) |
| Roadside inspections | No | No | Yes (3 years) |
| Drug-and-alcohol violations | No | No | No |
| Required by | §391.23(a)(1), §391.25(a) | §391.23(a)(1) for CDL | Voluntary (best practice) |
| FastDriverScreening package | $40 MVR Basic | $60 MVR + CDLIS | $80 DOT Hire-Ready |
MVR — the issuing-state license history
The Motor Vehicle Record is a state-level document. It is the issuing state DMV's official record of one driver's license: every action the state has taken on the license, every conviction the state has recorded, every accident the state knows about. The §391.23(a)(1) pre-employment rule requires an MVR from every state where the driver held a license in the prior three years.
What an MVR shows:
- Current license status (valid, suspended, revoked, cancelled, disqualified, expired)
- License class (A, B, C, or non-CDL operator) and endorsements (HazMat, tank, passenger, etc.)
- Restrictions (no air brake, manual transmission only, etc.)
- Medical certification status (most states; the §391.51 file still needs the underlying medical card)
- Convictions for traffic violations during the look-back period
- Suspensions, revocations, and administrative actions imposed by the state
What an MVR does not show:
- Anything from a state the driver does not currently hold a license in (and never held one in the look-back period)
- Crash data from carriers the driver worked for (PSP territory)
- Drug-and-alcohol program violations recorded with FMCSA (Clearinghouse territory)
The MVR is the most granular of the three reports for ordinary moving violations, but it is also the narrowest in scope — limited to one state at a time.
CDLIS — the cross-state CDL pointer
The Commercial Driver License Information System is a federally-mandated database operated by AAMVA (American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators). It is not a database of every driver's complete record; it is an index that, given a CDL holder's identifying information, returns every state where that driver has ever held a CDL or CDL learner's permit, plus the current license status in each.
What CDLIS shows:
- Every state where the driver has ever held a CDL or CDLP
- Current license status in each state (valid, suspended, disqualified, surrendered)
- Cross-state disqualifications under §383.73 reciprocity
- A pointer to the state of record (so the carrier knows which MVR to pull next)
What CDLIS does not show:
- Citation-level detail of any conviction (that is the underlying-state MVR's job)
- Non-CDL driver history (CDLIS is a CDL-only database by definition)
- Drug-and-alcohol violations (Clearinghouse territory)
- Crash or inspection history (PSP territory)
CDLIS is the only authoritative way to know which states' MVRs to pull. A driver who held a CDL in Texas, lost it for a serious offense, surrendered the license, moved to Florida, and obtained a new Florida CDL can present a clean Florida MVR. The CDLIS check surfaces the Texas history and tells the carrier to also pull a Texas MVR — which the §391.23(a)(1) "every state where the driver held a license in the prior three years" rule requires.
PSP — the on-the-road history at prior carriers
The Pre-Employment Screening Program is run by the FMCSA and pulls data from the Motor Carrier Management Information System (MCMIS). It reports two distinct datasets:
- 5 years of crash data (every crash recorded by a state to MCMIS while the driver was operating a commercial vehicle for any carrier)
- 3 years of inspection data (every roadside inspection of any vehicle the driver was operating, regardless of whether violations were issued)
What PSP shows:
- Crash date, location, and severity (PI = personal injury, PD = property damage, F = fatal)
- Whether the driver was issued a citation in connection with the crash
- Roadside inspection date, location, level (driver-only, vehicle-only, full)
- Driver-applicable violations (logbook, hours-of-service, license issues)
- Vehicle-applicable violations (brake adjustment, lights, tires) — these reflect on the prior carrier's vehicle, not the driver
What PSP does not show:
- Adjudicated fault for crashes (PSP is not a court record; fault analysis requires the police report)
- License-status history (MVR territory)
- Cross-state CDL holdings (CDLIS territory)
- Drug-and-alcohol program violations (Clearinghouse territory)
PSP is the only report that reveals on-the-road driver history at prior carriers — and it is the only report that includes inspection-level detail. A driver who has had three logbook violations in the prior eighteen months across two carriers will surface those violations on PSP even if no carrier-level dispute or audit ever occurred.
PSP is voluntary for carriers (not federally mandated for pre-employment), but it is the single most cost-effective screening layer for a CDL pre-employment package. The DOT Hire-Ready package at $80 adds PSP to the MVR + CDLIS bundle, and the DOT Pre-Employment package at $100 wraps in the FMCSA Clearinghouse pre-employment query that is mandatory under §382.701(a).
The three reports together
A complete CDL pre-employment file under §391.23, with all three reports plus the §382.701(a) Clearinghouse query, gives the carrier:
- License status and conviction history in every state where the driver held a license (MVR + CDLIS)
- On-the-road driver history at prior carriers, including crashes and roadside inspections (PSP)
- Drug-and-alcohol program violation history recorded with FMCSA (Clearinghouse)
Each gap that any one of the four leaves is filled by another. Skipping one creates a documented hole in the file the auditor will find.
A worked example
Take a hypothetical applicant: forty-five-year-old CDL driver applying for a long-haul position. The application says ten years at a single prior carrier, currently licensed in Tennessee, no prior states.
Run an MVR alone. The Tennessee MVR comes back clean — no convictions, valid Class A with a HazMat endorsement, current medical card. Without further information, the carrier might extend the offer.
Add a CDLIS check. It surfaces a prior Kentucky CDL the driver did not list, surrendered five years ago when the driver moved. A Kentucky MVR is now required under §391.23(a)(1). It comes back showing a serious violation seven years ago — outside the §383.51 lookback, so not a current disqualifier, but a §391.21 disclosure issue worth flagging.
Add a PSP report. It shows two recent at-fault crashes at the prior carrier (one $30K property damage, one minor PI) plus four logbook violations across the inspection record. None of these would have appeared on either MVR or on CDLIS — but every one is material to the hiring decision.
Add a Clearinghouse query. It returns "no information on file." The driver has no drug-and-alcohol program violations recorded with FMCSA.
The four reports together produce a complete picture. Any single one would have left a gap.
When each one is required
- Every CDL pre-employment screen — MVR, CDLIS, and Clearinghouse pre-employment query are all required under federal law (§391.23(a)(1) and §382.701(a)). PSP is strongly recommended but technically voluntary.
- Every non-CDL commercial driver pre-employment screen — MVR is required under §391.23(a)(1). CDLIS, PSP, and Clearinghouse do not apply (Clearinghouse is CDL-only by §382.103; CDLIS by definition; PSP is voluntary in either case but most carriers run it for any commercial hire).
- Every CDL annual review — MVR is required under §391.25. Clearinghouse limited query is required under §382.701(b). CDLIS is not required annually unless the driver had a state-of-residence change in the year. PSP is strongly recommended for any annual review of a long-haul driver.
- Every CDL annual review for a driver who had a state-of-residence change — MVR (every state) plus CDLIS (to confirm the new state issued the CDL correctly).
How they fit together at FastDriverScreening
The five-package catalog maps cleanly onto the report set:
- MVR Basic ($40) — single-state MVR for non-CDL annual reviews
- MVR + CDLIS ($60) — the §391.23 cross-state CDL check
- DOT Hire-Ready ($80) — adds PSP for pre-offer candidate vetting
- DOT Pre-Employment ($100) — adds the §382.701(a) Clearinghouse pre-employment query (the full §391.23 + §382 stack)
- Annual Refresh ($60) — MVR + §382.701(b) Clearinghouse limited query for the yearly recurring requirement
Pick the package by the regulatory step you are completing. For a CDL pre-employment screen, DOT Pre-Employment ($100) is the only package that satisfies §391.23(a)(1) plus §382.701(a) in a single order. For a non-CDL commercial driver, MVR Basic ($40) is sufficient. For a yearly compliance refresh on a long-tenured CDL driver, Annual Refresh ($60) covers the §382.701(b) and §391.25 requirements together.
Related guides
- CDLIS
CDLIS vs MVR: Why a Single-State Record Is Not Enough
A Motor Vehicle Record only shows what one state knows. CDLIS is the federal database of every CDL ever issued. Here is what each catches, what each misses, and when 49 CFR requires both.
- MVR
How to Read an MVR: A Line-by-Line Guide for Motor Carriers
Decode every section of a Motor Vehicle Record — license status codes, class and endorsements, restrictions, accidents, citations, suspensions — and learn which violations disqualify a CDL driver under 49 CFR §391.15.
- Compliance
FMCSA Clearinghouse Pre-Employment Query: A Step-by-Step Walkthrough
How to run an FMCSA Clearinghouse pre-employment query under 49 CFR §382.701(a) — driver consent flow, employer query, the 24-hour follow-up if a record is found, and what goes in the DQ file.
This guide is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. Verify every regulatory requirement against the current text of 49 CFR and consult qualified counsel for your specific situation.